Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop

Easter

All the Easter goodies you could want!

• 24K Carrot Layer Cake

  

  24K Carrot Layer Cake

  

  Regular price

  From $45.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $45.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $45.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $45.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Classic carrot cake made better with golden raisins!  Can be made with out without nuts.  Cream cheese icing.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6 inch (serves up to 10) 8 inch (serves 15-20) 10 inch (serves 25-30)

  6 inch (serves up to 10) 8 inch (serves 15-20) 10 inch (serves 25-30)

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• 24K Carrot Cupcakes

  

  24K Carrot Cupcakes

  

  Regular price

  From $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Decadent carrot cupcakes with golden raisins and cream cheese buttercream icing

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Half Dozen Dozen

  Half Dozen Dozen

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Easter white chocolate bunny

  

  Easter white chocolate bunny

  

  Regular price

  $8.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $8.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $8.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $8.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  White chocolate bunny- can be filled with cheesecake, peanut butter mousse or m&m’s candy.  

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Flavor Peanut butter mousse M&M’s

  Peanut butter mousse M&M’s - Sold Out

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Easter Paint-Your-Own Cookie Kit

  

  Easter Paint-Your-Own Cookie Kit

  

  Regular price

  $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Kit inludes 6 of our iced, egg shaped, sugar cookies - ready to be painted, edible paint palette and brush, instructi...

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title - Sold Out

  Sold Out Sold Out

  Quantity

• Easter cookies 6 pack

  

  Easter cookies 6 pack

  

  Regular price

  $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Assorted Easter cookie designs.

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Easter egg carton cake balls

  

  Easter egg carton cake balls

  

  Regular price

  $18.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $18.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $18.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $18.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Four pack of Easter cake balls packaged in cute hot pink egg cartons!  Flavors will be chocolate, strawberry, lemon a...

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6 pack

  6 pack

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

Showing 6 of 17 products on Easter collection

• Cheesecake

  

  Cheesecake

  

  Regular price

  From $22.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $22.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $45.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $45.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Decadent cheesecake in a myriad of flavor choices.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Full size 7 inch

  Flavor Lemon Curd Tuxedo Pumpkin Cherry Praline Espresso Strawberry Traditional plain

  Full size / Lemon Curd Full size / Tuxedo Full size / Pumpkin Full size / Cherry Full size / Praline Full size / Espresso Full size / Strawberry Full size / Traditional plain 7 inch / Lemon Curd 7 inch / Tuxedo 7 inch / Pumpkin 7 inch / Cherry 7 inch / Praline 7 inch / Espresso 7 inch / Strawberry 7 inch / Traditional plain

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Quiche

  

  Quiche

  

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Flavor Quiche Lorraine Spinach-Red Bell-Mushroom Mushroom-Leek Sausage-Green Chile-Corn

  Quiche Lorraine Spinach-Red Bell-Mushroom Mushroom-Leek Sausage-Green Chile-Corn

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Scones

  

  Scones

  

  Regular price

  From $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Yummy scones in a variety of flavor combinations, don't forget to add a jar of our homemade lemon curd or our compoun...

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Mini - 1 dozen Standard - 1/2 dozen Standard - 1 dozen

  Flavor Classic Cream Cherry almond Blueberry Lemon Poppyseed English Toffee Chocolate Chip Apricot White Chocolate Cranberry orange Candied orange-ginger Pumpkin (seasonal) Gingerbread (seasonal) Apple cinnamon

  Mini - 1 dozen / Classic Cream Mini - 1 dozen / Cherry almond Mini - 1 dozen / Blueberry Mini - 1 dozen / Lemon Poppyseed Mini - 1 dozen / English Toffee Mini - 1 dozen / Chocolate Chip Mini - 1 dozen / Apricot White Chocolate Mini - 1 dozen / Cranberry orange Mini - 1 dozen / Candied orange-ginger Mini - 1 dozen / Pumpkin (seasonal) Mini - 1 dozen / Gingerbread (seasonal) Mini - 1 dozen / Apple cinnamon Standard - 1/2 dozen / Classic Cream Standard - 1/2 dozen / Cherry almond Standard - 1/2 dozen / Blueberry Standard - 1/2 dozen / Lemon Poppyseed Standard - 1/2 dozen / English Toffee Standard - 1/2 dozen / Chocolate Chip Standard - 1/2 dozen / Apricot White Chocolate Standard - 1/2 dozen / Cranberry orange Standard - 1/2 dozen / Candied orange-ginger Standard - 1/2 dozen / Pumpkin (seasonal) Standard - 1/2 dozen / Gingerbread (seasonal) Standard - 1/2 dozen / Apple cinnamon Standard - 1 dozen / Classic Cream Standard - 1 dozen / Cherry almond Standard - 1 dozen / Blueberry Standard - 1 dozen / Lemon Poppyseed Standard - 1 dozen / English Toffee Standard - 1 dozen / Chocolate Chip Standard - 1 dozen / Apricot White Chocolate Standard - 1 dozen / Cranberry orange Standard - 1 dozen / Candied orange-ginger Standard - 1 dozen / Pumpkin (seasonal) Standard - 1 dozen / Gingerbread (seasonal) Standard - 1 dozen / Apple cinnamon

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Lemon-blueberry layer cake

  

  Lemon-blueberry layer cake

  

  Regular price

  From $45.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $45.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $45.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $45.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  3-layer lemon cake with blueberry compote and lemon curd filling, iced with buttercream and topped with more blueberr...

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6 inch (serves 8-10) 8 inch (serves 15-20) 10 inch (Serves 25-30)

  6 inch (serves 8-10) 8 inch (serves 15-20) 10 inch (Serves 25-30)

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Fruit Strudel

  

  Fruit Strudel

  

  Regular price

  From $20.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $20.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $38.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $38.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Flaky pastry surrounds a layer of cream cheese filling and fruit filling, powdered sugar icing drizzle.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Flavor Cherry Apple Blueberry Apple-Pear-Cranberry Size

  Size Full Half

  Cherry / Full Cherry / Half Apple / Full Apple / Half Blueberry / Full Blueberry / Half Apple-Pear-Cranberry / Full Apple-Pear-Cranberry / Half Size / Full Size / Half

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Lemon Meringue Pie

  

  Lemon Meringue Pie

  

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Just the right balance of tart and sweet!

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

Showing 6 of 12 products on Mother’s Day collection

• Teacher Appreciation cookies

  

  Teacher Appreciation cookies

  

  Regular price

  From $4.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $4.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Choose from assorted cookie designs and packages to show that special Teacher just how much you appreciate them!

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6 cookie box set Single cookie

  6 cookie box set Single cookie

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Dozen CSU or CU logo cookies

  

  Dozen CSU or CU logo cookies

  

  Regular price

  From $48.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $48.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $48.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $48.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Sold by the dozen, CSU Ram or CU Bison logo cookies.  Can be individually wrapped.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Style CSU - not ind bagged CSU - individually bagged CU - not ind bagged CU - individually bagged

  CSU - not ind bagged CSU - individually bagged CU - not ind bagged CU - individually bagged

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Graduation Cookies

  

  Graduation Cookies

  

  Regular price

  From $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $24.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $24.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Assorted designs available, can be customized with school logos. - please indicate school name/colors in the notes se...

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6 cookie box set Dozen assorted designs - not bagged Dozen assorted designs - individually bagged

  6 cookie box set Dozen assorted designs - not bagged Dozen assorted designs - individually bagged

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity