Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop

Cakes, Cheesecakes & Tortes

From layer cakes to tortes of all kinds - we've got you covered!

• Key Lime Pie

  

  Key Lime Pie

  

  Regular price

  $32.50 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $32.50 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $32.50 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $32.50 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Lip-smackin' good Key Lime Pie - just try it!

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Cheesecake

  

  Cheesecake

  

  Regular price

  From $22.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $22.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $45.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $45.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Decadent cheesecake in a myriad of flavor choices.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Full size 7 inch

  Flavor Lemon Curd Tuxedo Pumpkin Cherry Praline Espresso Strawberry Traditional plain

  Full size / Lemon Curd Full size / Tuxedo Full size / Pumpkin Full size / Cherry Full size / Praline Full size / Espresso Full size / Strawberry Full size / Traditional plain 7 inch / Lemon Curd 7 inch / Tuxedo 7 inch / Pumpkin 7 inch / Cherry 7 inch / Praline 7 inch / Espresso 7 inch / Strawberry 7 inch / Traditional plain

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• French Vanilla Layer Cake

  French Vanilla Layer Cake

  Regular price

  From $30.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $30.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $30.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $30.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  French vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6" (serves up to 10) 8" (serves up to 20) 10" (serves up to 30)

  Filing Vanilla Buttercream Strawberry Raspberry Blueberry Lemon Hazelnut buttercream Peanut butter Buttercream

  6" (serves up to 10) / Vanilla Buttercream 6" (serves up to 10) / Strawberry 6" (serves up to 10) / Raspberry 6" (serves up to 10) / Blueberry 6" (serves up to 10) / Lemon 6" (serves up to 10) / Hazelnut buttercream 6" (serves up to 10) / Peanut butter Buttercream 8" (serves up to 20) / Vanilla Buttercream 8" (serves up to 20) / Strawberry 8" (serves up to 20) / Raspberry 8" (serves up to 20) / Blueberry 8" (serves up to 20) / Lemon 8" (serves up to 20) / Hazelnut buttercream 8" (serves up to 20) / Peanut butter Buttercream 10" (serves up to 30) / Vanilla Buttercream 10" (serves up to 30) / Strawberry 10" (serves up to 30) / Raspberry 10" (serves up to 30) / Blueberry 10" (serves up to 30) / Lemon 10" (serves up to 30) / Hazelnut buttercream 10" (serves up to 30) / Peanut butter Buttercream

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• 24K Carrot Layer Cake

  

  24K Carrot Layer Cake

  

  Regular price

  From $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Classic carrot cake made better with golden raisins!  Can be made with out without nuts.  Cream cheese icing.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6 inch (serves up to 10) 8 inch (serves 15-20) 10 inch (serves 25-30)

  6 inch (serves up to 10) 8 inch (serves 15-20) 10 inch (serves 25-30)

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Chocolate Layer Cake

  

  Chocolate Layer Cake

  

  Regular price

  From $30.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $30.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $30.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $30.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6 inch - serves 8-10 8 inch - serves 15-20 10 inch - serves 25-30

  Filling Chocolate Buttercream Raspberry Strawberry Peanut butter buttercream Hazelnut buttercream Gran Marnier Ganache

  6 inch - serves 8-10 / Chocolate Buttercream 6 inch - serves 8-10 / Raspberry 6 inch - serves 8-10 / Strawberry 6 inch - serves 8-10 / Peanut butter buttercream 6 inch - serves 8-10 / Hazelnut buttercream 6 inch - serves 8-10 / Gran Marnier Ganache 8 inch - serves 15-20 / Chocolate Buttercream 8 inch - serves 15-20 / Raspberry 8 inch - serves 15-20 / Strawberry 8 inch - serves 15-20 / Peanut butter buttercream 8 inch - serves 15-20 / Hazelnut buttercream 8 inch - serves 15-20 / Gran Marnier Ganache 10 inch - serves 25-30 / Chocolate Buttercream 10 inch - serves 25-30 / Raspberry 10 inch - serves 25-30 / Strawberry 10 inch - serves 25-30 / Peanut butter buttercream 10 inch - serves 25-30 / Hazelnut buttercream 10 inch - serves 25-30 / Gran Marnier Ganache

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• German Chocolate Layer Cake

  

  German Chocolate Layer Cake

  

  Regular price

  From $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Layers of german chocolate cake with traditional coconut/pecan filling.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size 6 inch - serves 8-10 8 inch - serves 15-20 10 inch - serves 25-30

  6 inch - serves 8-10 8 inch - serves 15-20 10 inch - serves 25-30

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

Showing 6 of 18 products on Cakes, Cheesecakes & Tortes collection

• Key Lime Pie

  

  Key Lime Pie

  

  Regular price

  $32.50 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $32.50 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $32.50 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $32.50 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Lip-smackin' good Key Lime Pie - just try it!

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Apple Pie

  

  Apple Pie

  

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Classic lattice top apple pie

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Cherry Pie

  

  Cherry Pie

  

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Two kinds of cherries in our buttery, flaky crust.

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Banana Cream Pie

  

  Banana Cream Pie

  

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  You'll find lots of fresh sliced bananas in our banana cream pie, topped with fresh whipped cream.

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Caramel Apple Pie

  

  Caramel Apple Pie

  

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Classic apple pie made even better with caramel drizzled through it!

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Coconut Cream Pie

  

  Coconut Cream Pie

  

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $29.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $29.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Coconut custard topped with fresh whipped cream and more toasted coconut.

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Default Title

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

Showing 6 of 18 products on Pies collection

• Quiche

  

  Quiche

  

  Regular price

  $30.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $30.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $30.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $30.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Flavor Quiche Lorraine Spinach-Red Bell-Mushroom Mushroom-Leek Sausage-Green Chile-Corn

  Quiche Lorraine Spinach-Red Bell-Mushroom Mushroom-Leek Sausage-Green Chile-Corn

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Fruit Strudel

  

  Fruit Strudel

  

  Regular price

  From $18.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $18.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $32.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $32.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Flaky pastry surrounds a layer of cream cheese filling and fruit filling, powdered sugar icing drizzle.

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Flavor Cherry Apple Blueberry Apple-Pear-Cranberry Size

  Size Full Half

  Cherry / Full Cherry / Half Apple / Full Apple / Half Blueberry / Full Blueberry / Half Apple-Pear-Cranberry / Full Apple-Pear-Cranberry / Half Size / Full Size / Half

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Pot Pies

  

  Pot Pies

  

  Regular price

  From $12.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $12.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Try our yummy pie crust with savory herbs added and filled to the brim with your choice of yummy filling!

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Flavor Traditional Chicken Guinness Beef Pot Roast Pork and Green Chile

  Size 9" Family Size Pie Individual Pie

  Baked or Frozen Ready to Bake Ready to Eat

  Traditional Chicken / 9" Family Size Pie / Ready to Bake Traditional Chicken / 9" Family Size Pie / Ready to Eat Traditional Chicken / Individual Pie / Ready to Bake Traditional Chicken / Individual Pie / Ready to Eat Guinness Beef / 9" Family Size Pie / Ready to Bake Guinness Beef / 9" Family Size Pie / Ready to Eat Guinness Beef / Individual Pie / Ready to Bake Guinness Beef / Individual Pie / Ready to Eat Pot Roast / 9" Family Size Pie / Ready to Bake Pot Roast / 9" Family Size Pie / Ready to Eat Pot Roast / Individual Pie / Ready to Bake Pot Roast / Individual Pie / Ready to Eat Pork and Green Chile / 9" Family Size Pie / Ready to Bake Pork and Green Chile / 9" Family Size Pie / Ready to Eat Pork and Green Chile / Individual Pie / Ready to Bake Pork and Green Chile / Individual Pie / Ready to Eat

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Breakfast Bake

  

  Breakfast Bake

  

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $35.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $35.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Croissant dough base, fluffy eggs and cheese, and either sausage or vegetables

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Flavor Breakfast sausage Vegetable

  Breakfast sausage Vegetable

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Scones

  

  Scones

  

  Regular price

  From $12.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $12.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $12.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $12.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Yummy scones in a variety of flavor combinations, don't forget to add a jar of our homemade lemon curd or our compoun...

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Mini - 1 dozen Standard - 1/2 dozen Standard - 1 dozen

  Flavor Classic Cream Cherry almond Blueberry Lemon Poppyseed English Toffee Chocolate Chip Apricot White Chocolate Cranberry orange Candied orange-ginger Pumpkin (seasonal) Gingerbread (seasonal) Apple cinnamon

  Mini - 1 dozen / Classic Cream Mini - 1 dozen / Cherry almond Mini - 1 dozen / Blueberry Mini - 1 dozen / Lemon Poppyseed Mini - 1 dozen / English Toffee Mini - 1 dozen / Chocolate Chip Mini - 1 dozen / Apricot White Chocolate Mini - 1 dozen / Cranberry orange Mini - 1 dozen / Candied orange-ginger Mini - 1 dozen / Pumpkin (seasonal) Mini - 1 dozen / Gingerbread (seasonal) Mini - 1 dozen / Apple cinnamon Standard - 1/2 dozen / Classic Cream Standard - 1/2 dozen / Cherry almond Standard - 1/2 dozen / Blueberry Standard - 1/2 dozen / Lemon Poppyseed Standard - 1/2 dozen / English Toffee Standard - 1/2 dozen / Chocolate Chip Standard - 1/2 dozen / Apricot White Chocolate Standard - 1/2 dozen / Cranberry orange Standard - 1/2 dozen / Candied orange-ginger Standard - 1/2 dozen / Pumpkin (seasonal) Standard - 1/2 dozen / Gingerbread (seasonal) Standard - 1/2 dozen / Apple cinnamon Standard - 1 dozen / Classic Cream Standard - 1 dozen / Cherry almond Standard - 1 dozen / Blueberry Standard - 1 dozen / Lemon Poppyseed Standard - 1 dozen / English Toffee Standard - 1 dozen / Chocolate Chip Standard - 1 dozen / Apricot White Chocolate Standard - 1 dozen / Cranberry orange Standard - 1 dozen / Candied orange-ginger Standard - 1 dozen / Pumpkin (seasonal) Standard - 1 dozen / Gingerbread (seasonal) Standard - 1 dozen / Apple cinnamon

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Quickbreads and Muffins

  Quickbreads and Muffins

  Regular price

  From $6.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $6.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $10.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $10.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Choose from a nice selection of flavors and a variety of sizes including Full Loaf, Tea Bread, and Muffin

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Flavor Banana Bread Chocolate Chip Banana Bread Banana Bread with Pecans Banana Bread with Walnuts Zucchini Bread Pumpkin Bread Lemon-Poppyseed Bread Cinnamon Apple Cranberry-Orange Lemon Lemon-Blueberry Cinnamon-Struesel Blueberry muffins

  Size Full Loaf Tea bread size Muffins - 1/2 dozen Muffins - Dozen 1/2 dozen

  Banana Bread / Full Loaf Banana Bread / Tea bread size Banana Bread / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Banana Bread / Muffins - Dozen Chocolate Chip Banana Bread / Full Loaf Chocolate Chip Banana Bread / Tea bread size Chocolate Chip Banana Bread / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Chocolate Chip Banana Bread / Muffins - Dozen Banana Bread with Pecans / Full Loaf Banana Bread with Pecans / Tea bread size Banana Bread with Pecans / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Banana Bread with Pecans / Muffins - Dozen Banana Bread with Walnuts / Full Loaf Banana Bread with Walnuts / Tea bread size Banana Bread with Walnuts / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Banana Bread with Walnuts / Muffins - Dozen Zucchini Bread / Full Loaf Zucchini Bread / Tea bread size Zucchini Bread / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Zucchini Bread / Muffins - Dozen Pumpkin Bread / Full Loaf Pumpkin Bread / Tea bread size Pumpkin Bread / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Pumpkin Bread / Muffins - Dozen Lemon-Poppyseed Bread / Full Loaf Lemon-Poppyseed Bread / Tea bread size Lemon-Poppyseed Bread / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Lemon-Poppyseed Bread / Muffins - Dozen Cinnamon Apple / Full Loaf Cinnamon Apple / Tea bread size Cinnamon Apple / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Cinnamon Apple / Muffins - Dozen Cranberry-Orange / Full Loaf Cranberry-Orange / Tea bread size Cranberry-Orange / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Cranberry-Orange / Muffins - Dozen Lemon / Full Loaf Lemon / Tea bread size Lemon / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Lemon / Muffins - Dozen Lemon-Blueberry / Full Loaf Lemon-Blueberry / Tea bread size Lemon-Blueberry / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Lemon-Blueberry / Muffins - Dozen Cinnamon-Struesel / Full Loaf Cinnamon-Struesel / Tea bread size Cinnamon-Struesel / Muffins - 1/2 dozen Cinnamon-Struesel / Muffins - Dozen Blueberry muffins / 1/2 dozen - Sold Out

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

Showing 6 of 12 products on Baked Goods collection

Cupcakes, Cake Balls, Cookies

Choose from any of our yummy flavors or get an assortment!  We currently offer our cupcakes, cake balls and cookies in half-dozen and dozen packages.  Need custom decoration?  We can do that too!  Just give us a call or send us a message and we'll get started!

• 24K Carrot Cupcakes

  

  24K Carrot Cupcakes

  

  Regular price

  From $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Decadent carrot cupcakes with golden raisins and cream cheese buttercream icing

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Half Dozen Dozen

  Half Dozen Dozen

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Assorted Cupcakes

  

  Assorted Cupcakes

  

  Regular price

  From $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Chef's daily selection of assorted flavored cupcakes.  Perfect to take to the office or as a gift!

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Half Dozen Dozen

  Half Dozen Dozen

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Back to School - sugar cookies

  

  Back to School - sugar cookies

  

  Regular price

  From $12.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $12.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $12.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $12.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Sugar cookies:   “Good luck with my kid” has two extra large cookies,  the assorted box has 6 regular size cookies

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Design Good luck with my kid Assorted school designs

  Good luck with my kid Assorted school designs

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Blueberry-Lemon Cupcakes

  

  Blueberry-Lemon Cupcakes

  

  Regular price

  From $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Half Dozen Dozen

  Half Dozen Dozen

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Chocolate Cupcakes

  

  Chocolate Cupcakes

  

  Regular price

  From $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Half Dozen Dozen

  Half Dozen Dozen

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

• Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcakes

  

  Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcakes

  

  Regular price

  From $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  From $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  Regular price

  $15.00 USD

  Regular price

  Sale price

  $15.00 USD

  Sale Sold Out

  Unit price

  /per 

  View details

  Show Options

  Error Quantity must be 1 or more

  Size Half Dozen Dozen

  Half Dozen Dozen

  Add to Cart Add to Cart

  Quantity

Showing 6 of 48 products on Cupcakes, Cake Balls, Cookies collection