Wedding Cakes

Our custom wedding cakes are unique and specially designed for you and your partner! Starting price is $3/serving; Vegan and Gluten-Free are an additional $1-$2/serving. Starting prices shown are for our simple buttercream wedding cakes. Design elements like fondant covered, hand-painted gold details, sugar flowers, sugar lace, fondant ruffles, etc. will be an additional charge and based on design.

Each cake tier consists of three layers of cake with filling in between, making them about 5-6" tall. You can choose one cake flavor and one filling flavor per tier. Wedding cakes should serve about 70-75% of your guests, especially other sweets will be served (like ice cream or a dessert bar).

Fresh flowers are not included or provided by Buttermilk Bakery. We can work closely with your florist to customize a design that incorporates fresh flowers selected for your event.

Delivery and setup fees vary and are based on distance from our shop, size of the cake being assembled on-site, florals being arranged on the cake on-site, etc. For the safety of your cake, we do require that we deliver any cake that is larger than two tiers.

Following is a list of cake flavors and fillings that we offer, some are seasonal, and this is certainly not every flavor we have ever made and we are also always open to special requests, so please ask if you don't see what you are looking for.

French Vanilla Buttercream
Chocolate Fudge Cream Cheese Buttercream
Red Velvet Pastry Cream
Crème Brulée  Lemon Curd
White Chocolate Lime Curd
Amaretto Blood Orange Curd
Lemon Passionfruit-Lime
Strawberry Blackberry-Ginger
Blackberry Strawberry
Dark Chocolate Cherry Strawberry-Rhubarb
Masala Chai Kiwi
German Chocolate Guava
Italian Cream Guava-Blueberry
Guava Chiffon Blueberry Compote
Carrot Raspberry
Coconut Cinnamon Apple
S'mores Cherry
Brown Sugar Peach Caramel Apple
Rose-Pistachio Cherry-Almond
Berry Chantilly (in season) Chocolate pastry cream
Persimmon (in season) Chocolate whipped ganache
Hummingbird Pineapple
Strawberry Margarita Pomegranate
Mojito Caramel Mousse
Chocolate Salted Caramel Dulce De Leche buttercream
Butter Pecan Espresso Mascarpone Cream
Pumpkin Spice Moroccan Orange Curd
Spice Cranberry-Orange compote
Banana Peanut Butter buttercream
Pumpkin Cream